We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance,
functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you
are agreeing to our privacy policy
10 Best Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt
From leading brands and best sellers available on the web.
Related Products
Recommended lists
Buying Guide for the Best Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt
Choosing the right fastpitch softball first base mitt is important for both comfort and performance. A mitt that fits well and is suited to your playing style can help you catch balls with ease, protect your hand, and play confidently. When shopping, you should focus on a few key specs that affect usability, durability, and comfort. Think about your hand size, the level at which you play, and your usual fielding style. If possible, try on a few mitts or mimic catching motions to sense what feels most natural. Knowing these key features and how to read them before buying can make your choice much easier and more satisfying.SizeThe size of a first base mitt is measured in inches and typically ranges from around 12 to 13 inches. The size refers to the length of the mitt from the top of the index finger to the bottom of the heel. For youth players or those with smaller hands, a smaller mitt (around 12 to 12.5 inches) makes it easier to control and close the glove securely. Larger mitts (up to 13 inches) provide more surface area for catching, which can be helpful for advanced or adult players who need to scoop up throws more easily. The best size for you depends on your hand size and comfort—if a mitt is too large, it can be difficult to handle; if too small, it may not provide enough coverage.
WebbingThe webbing refers to the pattern of leather or materials connecting the thumb and fingers of the mitt, influencing both visibility and control. First base mitts usually feature open or closed webbing styles. Open webbing is popular because it helps players see the ball better and makes it easier to catch and scoop balls out of the dirt. Closed webbing offers extra support and structure, which can be useful for holding onto harder throws. Your preference here should be based on whether you like more flexibility and visibility (open web) or extra firmness and support (closed web).
MaterialFirst base mitts are commonly made from synthetic materials or different grades of leather. Synthetic options are lighter, less expensive, and easier to break in, making them good for casual or younger players. Full-grain or steerhide leather is more durable and forms a better pocket over time, often used by serious or competitive players. Premium leathers take longer to break in but last much longer and offer a better fit as they mold to your hand. Choose synthetic materials for quick use and convenience, or high-quality leather if you plan to use your mitt often and want a custom fit after break-in.
PaddingPadding in a first base mitt protects your hand from the impact of hard throws and helps reduce sting. Some mitts have extra padding around the palm, fingers, and thumb. Thicker padding is ideal for competitive players facing harder throws, while lighter padding keeps the mitt lighter and can be more comfortable for young or recreational players. Consider your playing level and how often you catch fast throws when selecting the amount of padding to balance protection and comfort.
Fit and AdjustabilityFit refers to how snugly the mitt sits on your hand, influenced by both inner lining and adjustable features like wrist straps or laces. A secure fit improves control and confidence—look for mitts with adjustable features if you have hands that are smaller or larger than average. The lining material can also affect comfort and sweat management. Try to pick a mitt that feels snug but not tight and allows you to quickly open and close your hand inside the glove.