We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance,
functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you
are agreeing to our privacy policy
10 Best Grilled Cheese Makers
From leading brands and best sellers available on the web.By clicking on a link to a third party's website, log data is shared with that third party.
Related Products
Up to 22% off
Buying Guide for the Best Grilled Cheese Makers
Choosing the right grilled cheese maker can make your kitchen experience more enjoyable and your sandwiches tastier. To find the best fit for you, first think about how often you'll use it, how much space you have, and how many sandwiches you want to make at once. The key is to match the features of the grilled cheese maker to your habits and preferences so making grilled cheese is easy, quick, and gives the results you want.Plate MaterialThe plate material refers to the part of the grilled cheese maker that touches your bread and cheese as it cooks. This is important because it affects how evenly your sandwich gets toasted and how easy it is to clean up afterward. Most commonly, plates are either nonstick-coated or made from ceramic. Nonstick plates make it simple to remove your sandwich and wipe up any melted cheese, but may wear out over time, while ceramic plates tend to last longer and are more resistant to scratches but sometimes food can stick a bit more. If you dislike scrubbing or want quick cleanup, nonstick is a good choice. For durability and less chemical coating, ceramic might suit you better.
Cooking CapacityCooking capacity means how many sandwiches you can make in one go. Some makers are single-sandwich sized, while others let you prepare two or even four sandwiches at once. This matters depending on whether you're cooking just for yourself or for several people. If you mostly cook for one or two, a smaller grilled cheese maker will be compact and efficient. For families or groups, a larger capacity will save time and allow everyone to eat together.
Heat SettingsHeat settings control how hot your grilled cheese maker gets, which influences how brown and crispy your sandwiches turn out. Some makers have a simple on/off switch, while others give you adjustable temperature controls or multiple pre-set options. If you're particular about getting your bread just the right shade of golden or want to experiment with different fillings and thicknesses, having variable heat will be useful. If you prefer a straightforward, no-fuss approach, a basic single-setting model will work just fine.
Indicator LightsIndicator lights are small lamps that tell you when the maker is preheated or when your sandwiches are done. This is important for not undercooking or burning your food and for convenience—especially if you’re multitasking in the kitchen. Some models have one light for power and another for ready status, while simple versions may not have any indicators. If you like clear cues and user-friendliness, look for a model with helpful indicator lights.
Ease of CleaningEase of cleaning depends on whether the grilling plates are removable and dishwasher-safe or fixed and require a wipe-down. Sandwich makers with removable plates make cleaning up much easier, especially when cheese or fillings spill. If you value quick and thorough cleaning, opt for removable, dishwasher-safe pieces. If you don’t mind a bit of manual work and want a slimmer design, fixed plates might suit you.
Size and StorageSize and storage refer to how much space the grilled cheese maker takes up on your counter or in a cabinet. Larger models take more space but offer more features or capacity, while compact ones are easier to store but may limit your sandwich-making ability. Think about your kitchen space and how often you'll use the maker—if you want to leave it out, size might not matter as much. If you have little storage, a compact and easily stowable option is best.