We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance,
functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you
are agreeing to our privacy policy
10 Best Youth Softball Catchers Mitt
From leading brands and best sellers available on the web.
Related Products
Recommended lists
Top rated
Youth Catchers Sets
Buying Guide for the Best Youth Softball Catchers Mitt
Choosing the right youth softball catcher's mitt is important because it helps young players develop their skills, protects their hand, and builds their confidence behind the plate. Finding the best fit means thinking about comfort, safety, size, and ease of use. Instead of getting overwhelmed by all the mitts on the market, focus on a few key specifications that influence how the mitt will perform and feel in your child’s hand. Take into account the player’s age, experience, hand size, and position when making your choice.SizeSize refers to the overall length of the mitt, usually measured in inches and typically falls between 31 and 34 inches for youth. This spec is crucial because a mitt that's too big will be hard for a young player to control, while something too small may not provide enough catching area or protection. Generally, younger or smaller players should opt for mitts on the smaller side (about 31-32 inches), while older or bigger youths can look in the 32.5-34 inch range. Let the child try on different sizes to see what is easiest for them to open, close, and maneuver. Remember, the right size boosts confidence and safety.
WebbingWebbing is the part of the mitt between the thumb and fingers, and in catcher’s mitts, it’s usually solid or closed, providing more support and better ball control. Solid webbing is best for catchers because it handles repeated fast pitches and blocks dirt. The importance here is durability and the ability to support catching high-speed throws, while helping to shield the ball from view. All youth catcher's mitts generally come with closed webbing, so your main concern should be how stiff or flexible the web is when new; beginners may benefit from a slightly more flexible web to help with closing the mitt.
PaddingPadding is the protective material in the palm and fingers, and it's especially important for catchers who constantly face hard-thrown balls. More padding equals more hand protection, while less padding can make the mitt easier to flex. Younger or less experienced players should look for mitts with thicker, softer padding to help prevent stings and injuries, as they are still developing catching technique. As skill increases and hand strength develops, players might prefer a mitt with slightly less padding for more control, but safety should always come first for youth.
MaterialMaterial refers to what the mitt is made from—most commonly synthetic leather or genuine leather. Leather is more durable and molds to the hand over time, while synthetic mitts are lighter, less expensive, and break in more quickly. For younger or casual players, synthetic may be easier to start with, as it requires less break-in and is generally more comfortable right out of the box. Older or more serious youth players may want to go with genuine leather, as it will last longer and form to the hand, but remember it will also need more time to soften up and become game-ready.
Fit and AdjustabilityFit and adjustability describes how well the mitt stays on the hand and how easy it is to customize the feel. Many youth mitts include adjustable wrist straps or Velcro closures to help get a snug, secure fit. This is important because a mitt that slips or feels loose can be distracting and hard to use, while one that’s too tight is uncomfortable. Be sure your child can easily fit their hand in the mitt and make simple adjustments so it feels secure. Prioritize mitts with good adjustability, especially for younger players who are still growing.